What are the best can openers according to America’s Test Kitchen (ATK)? ATK tests many can openers to find the ones that work well, last a long time, and are easy to use. This guide shares their top picks for both manual and electric models.
Why Trust ATK’s Testing on Can Openers
America’s Test Kitchen is famous for its tough testing. They don’t just look at how an opener works once. They use it many times on different types of cans. They check for ease of use, safety, and how well it cuts. Their goal is to find the best tools for your kitchen. This deep dive looks at what makes their top picks stand out. We gather the best manual can opener reviews and electric models they endorse.
Deciphering Can Opener Types
There are two main types of can openers: manual and electric. Each has pros and cons. ATK looks closely at both.
Manual Can Openers: Simple and Reliable
Manual openers are great because they need no power. They are small and easy to store. ATK likes models that don’t make you work too hard.
Key Features ATK Tests for Manual Openers
When testing manual openers, ATK focuses on several key areas:
- Ease of Turning: Does the handle turn smoothly? Does it slip?
- Grip Comfort: Are the handles shaped well? Do they hurt your hand after opening a few cans?
- Cutting Power: Does it pierce the lid easily? Does it cut cleanly all the way around?
- Lid Removal: How easy is it to get the lid off once cut?
Electric Can Openers: Power and Convenience
Electric models are best for people with weak hands or for opening many cans fast. ATK judges these on speed and consistency.
Key Features ATK Tests for Electric Openers
Electric openers need more checks than manual ones:
- Motor Strength: Can it handle tough, thick metal cans?
- Smooth Operation: Does it cut smoothly without jerking?
- Safety Features: Does it have a clean cut? Does it drop the lid safely?
- Bottle Opener/Knife Sharpener: Do these extra tools work well?
Top ATK Favorite Can Openers: Manual Picks
ATK often finds that simple tools do the best job. Here are the manual openers that usually score high in their tests.
The Best Manual Can Opener: Smooth Edge Champions
Many people hate sharp edges on opened cans. ATK puts a special focus on smooth edge can opener comparison. These models cut along the side seam, leaving a smooth rim.
| Model Tested | Cutting Style | Ease of Use Score (1-10) | Notes from ATK Testing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kuhn Rikon Safety-Lock | Side-Cut (Smooth Edge) | 9.5 | Excellent grip; very smooth edge left behind. |
| OXO Good Grips | Side-Cut (Smooth Edge) | 9.0 | Comfortable large handles; reliable operation. |
| Swing-A-Way Classic | Top-Cut (Traditional) | 8.5 | Very strong build; slightly sharper edge than smooth cut models. |
Detailed Review: The Kuhn Rikon Can Opener Review
The Kuhn Rikon can opener review often highlights this model. ATK loves its strong build. It uses a high-quality steel cutting wheel. It grips the can rim firmly. This means less slipping while you turn. For those seeking the best manual experience, the Kuhn Rikon is often the top choice in America’s Test Kitchen can opener recommendations.
Detailed Review: The OXO Can Opener Review
The OXO can opener review usually praises its design for comfort. OXO focuses on ergonomics. Their can openers have thick, soft handles. This makes them a top pick for a durable can opener for seniors or anyone with hand fatigue. It performs well in speed tests, too.
Choosing the Best Budget Manual Opener
Not everyone wants to spend a lot of money. ATK also looks for value. The best budget can opener ATK praises is usually strong but lacks some fancy features. It focuses purely on cutting well.
- Look for simple, all-metal construction.
- Avoid plastic parts, even in budget models, for better life.
- Check user reviews for reports of rust.
Top ATK Electric Can Opener Recommendations
Electric openers save time and effort. ATK grades them on how quickly they open a can and how reliably they clamp onto the lid.
Smooth Cut Electric Openers: Safety First
Smooth edge electric openers are often preferred. They lift the lid off the side seam. This means no sharp metal edge sticks up.
Testing Electric Opener Consistency
ATK testers often open ten cans in a row with the same model. They look for fading power. Does the opener slow down halfway through the batch? A top-rated electric model keeps its speed and strength consistent.
The Best Electric Can Opener Recommendations
When ATK names its electric can opener recommendations, they usually favor models that are simple to use. Complex features often fail first.
- One-Touch Operation: The best models clamp on by themselves and stop automatically.
- Stable Base: The opener must not move or tip over while running.
- Easy Cleaning: Since food often touches the cutting wheel, it must be easy to wipe clean.
Making the Right Choice: Your Personal Needs
The can opener buying guide America’s Test Kitchen emphasizes that the “best” opener depends on you. Think about how often you use it and who will use it.
For Heavy Daily Use
If you open many cans daily (like in a busy home or small business), you need a heavy-duty manual opener or a robust electric one. Look for full metal construction. Manual openers like the strong Swing-A-Way often win here for sheer longevity.
For Seniors or Those with Limited Strength
Hand strength is key here. For manual use, focus on models with large, padded handles that offer more leverage. The OXO model often shines here. For electric use, any reliable one-touch model is excellent. It removes the need for gripping and turning entirely.
For Small Kitchens and Travel
If space is limited, a manual opener is better. They take up very little drawer space. Look for models that fold up compactly or have a magnetic holder feature.
Deep Dive into Cutting Mechanisms
The way a can opener cuts determines the final lid edge. This is crucial for safety and cleanup.
Top-Cut Openers (Traditional)
These openers pierce the top of the lid. They cut a circle just inside the rim.
- Pros: Often faster; simple mechanism means fewer parts to break.
- Cons: Leaves a very sharp, jagged edge on the lid and the can rim. Requires careful handling.
Side-Cut Openers (Smooth Edge)
These models fit around the can’s outer rim. They cut the seal between the lid and the can body.
- Pros: Leaves smooth, dull edges on both the can and the lid. Safer for handling waste and getting food out.
- Cons: Can be slightly slower; requires precise alignment when starting the cut.
ATK strongly favors side-cut openers due to the safety benefits. They are key components in any modern smooth edge can opener comparison.
Durability and Material Quality
A good can opener should last years, not months. ATK checks materials closely.
Stainless Steel vs. Plated Metal
Look for openers made primarily of stainless steel. This resists rust, especially important if the opener gets wet frequently or is stored near the sink. Cheaper openers often use plated metal that can chip or rust over time. A durable can opener for seniors must not rust, as handling slick, rusty tools is dangerous.
Gear Quality
In electric models, the internal gears must be strong plastic or metal. Plastic gears are common to keep costs down, but heavy-duty testers find they strip easily under pressure. Metal gearing usually equals a longer lifespan.
Advanced Features: Are They Worth It?
Some can openers come with built-in extras. Should you pay more for them?
Magnetic Lid Holders
Many electric openers feature a magnet that holds the lid once it’s cut. This prevents the lid from falling into your food. ATK views this as a major convenience feature, though not essential for cutting performance.
Integrated Bottle Openers and Knife Sharpeners
These are nice add-ons, but ATK testing shows they are rarely as good as dedicated tools. A separate bottle opener or sharpener usually performs better. If you buy an opener just for these features, you might be disappointed.
How to Use ATK’s Findings: Shopping Tips
Use this information when browsing reviews or stores. Look for the model names ATK favors.
Reading the Reviews
When you see best manual can opener reviews, check if the reviewer mentions ATK or similar rigorous testing. Look for consistent performance across different can sizes (small tuna cans to large vegetable cans).
Evaluating the Price Point
Sometimes, the most expensive opener isn’t the best. Sometimes, the best budget can opener ATK finds outperforms mid-range models. Generally, expect to pay more for reliable smooth-edge technology, whether manual or electric.
| Price Range | Expected Quality/Features | ATK Focus |
|---|---|---|
| Under $15 | Basic top-cut manual openers. Limited durability. | Value, basic function. |
| $15 – $30 | Good manual smooth-edge options (like OXO or Kuhn Rikon). Entry-level electrics. | Ergonomics, reliable cutting. |
| $30+ | High-end electric openers, premium manual designs. | Motor strength, long-term durability, smooth cut consistency. |
Maintenance Tips for Long-Lasting Performance
Even the best openers need care. Follow these steps to keep your opener working perfectly, as advised by kitchen experts.
Cleaning Manual Openers
After use, wipe down the cutting wheel and gear mechanism immediately. Food residue can cause rust or make the gears stick. Avoid submerging manual openers in water unless the packaging specifically allows it.
Caring for Electric Openers
Unplug the unit before cleaning. Use a damp cloth to wipe the exterior. For the cutting mechanism, use a soft brush (like an old toothbrush) to remove any dried food bits around the wheel and magnet. Never spray cleaner directly into the motor housing.
Addressing Common Can Opener Issues
Sometimes, even the best openers face trouble. Here is what ATK advises when things go wrong.
The Opener Slips on the Can
This is common with older or poorly designed models.
- Check the Grip: Make sure the turning knob (on manual models) or the clamping arms (on electric models) are engaging the can firmly.
- Test the Angle: If using a manual side-cut, ensure you are turning the opener handle in a smooth, constant circle. Jerking causes slippage.
The Cut Isn’t Clean
If the lid remains partially attached, the cutting wheel is likely dull or misaligned.
- Manual: If the wheel looks worn down or the cutting point is rounded, it’s time for a new one. A durable can opener for seniors should maintain its edge longer.
- Electric: If the alignment seems off, check if the opener base is level. If the motor is struggling, it may indicate wear or low power.
Final Thoughts on ATK’s Favorite Tools
America’s Test Kitchen continually reinforces that quality tools make cooking easier and safer. When it comes to can openers, they steer us toward models that prioritize a clean cut, comfortable use, and lasting materials. Whether you prefer the simplicity of a Kuhn Rikon can opener review winner or the speed of top electric can opener recommendations, ATK’s rigorous standards help you invest wisely.
This detailed can opener buying guide America’s Test Kitchen provides the blueprint. Focus on smooth edge models for safety and choose a brand known for durability. Your kitchen work will become much smoother.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Does America’s Test Kitchen still recommend manual can openers over electric ones?
Yes, ATK often prefers the best manual can opener reviews winners because they are simpler, last longer, and don’t rely on electricity or batteries. However, they highly recommend electric models for users who need assistance with hand strength.
Are smooth edge can openers worth the extra cost?
Yes. ATK testing shows that smooth edge models significantly reduce the risk of cuts from sharp metal edges on both the lid and the can opening. They greatly improve safety.
What is the most durable can opener brand according to ATK testing?
Brands like Kuhn Rikon and certain heavy-duty models from Swing-A-Way often score high for durability due to their robust metal construction and simple mechanics.
How often should I replace my can opener?
If you use a manual opener daily, expect to replace it every 5 to 10 years, depending on wear to the cutting wheel. If an opener starts requiring excessive force or creates jagged cuts, replace it immediately for safety.
Can an electric can opener dull over time?
Yes, the cutting mechanism on electric openers can wear down, especially the grinding wheel. If the opener starts struggling with standard cans, it’s a sign that performance is declining, and replacement is needed.